Cole St. James

Background and Early Life Born on October 3, 1997, in SteelPort City, Cole St. James grew up surrounded by the bright lights and bustling energy of Avalon’s largest metropolis. The youngest of three siblings, Cole was the family’s performer from an early age, always seeking the spotlight during family gatherings and school plays. His theatrical flair and natural charisma were impossible to ignore, paving the way for his initial career as a stage actor.   Education and Theater Career Cole attended a performing arts academy in SteelPort City, excelling in dramatic arts and earning lead roles in local productions. His standout performance as Hamlet at just 20 years old earned him accolades and attention from Avalon’s theater scene. However, the unpredictability of acting—along with a desire to tell stories beyond the stage—pushed Cole toward new creative outlets.   Transition to Podcasting Cole met Jim and Emily Harrington through mutual friends during an event in SteelPort City. Initially skeptical of true crime—finding it too grim for his dramatic sensibilities—Cole was drawn to the Harringtons’ passion for storytelling and their vision for Murder, Mysteries, and Avalon. The idea of blending real-life mysteries with theatrical storytelling intrigued him, and he joined the team as the podcast’s third host.   Cole’s presence brought a new energy to the podcast, helping it stand out in a crowded market. His ability to weave suspense and humor into the darkest tales earned him a loyal fanbase, and his dramatic reenactments of key events became a signature element of the show.   Role on the Podcast As the flamboyant wildcard of Murder, Mysteries, and Avalon, Cole serves as the emotional and theatrical counterbalance to Jim’s pragmatism and Emily’s empathy. He often takes the lead in engaging the audience, delivering dramatic flourishes and injecting levity into otherwise heavy topics.   Key Contributions: Storytelling Flair: Cole’s theatrical delivery transforms dry facts into compelling narratives, captivating listeners and adding a sense of drama to the podcast. Audience Engagement: Cole frequently interacts with fans on social media, where his wit and charm shine. His weekly Q&A sessions and live streams have become staples of the podcast’s outreach. Research with a Twist: While Jim and Emily focus on facts and interviews, Cole dives into the cultural and folkloric aspects of cases, adding depth and intrigue to episodes. Notable Episodes and Moments "The Wraith of Cleary Lake" Cole’s dramatic reenactment of the final moments of a Cleary Lake victim became one of the podcast’s most talked-about moments. His ability to humanize the victim while maintaining the suspense of the story solidified his role as a key storyteller.   "Sins of the GodFather" Cole brought his theatrical energy to the analysis of TheGodFather’s Seven Deadly Sins murders. His haunting delivery of excerpts from the killer’s manifesto added an unsettling yet mesmerizing layer to the episode.   "The Well Outside Carcer City" During Jim Harrington's near-fatal encounter with a cougar, Cole provided levity and comfort, lightening the tension with his humor while ensuring Jim’s story remained impactful. His recounting of the incident—complete with his own dramatized “cougar noises”—became a fan favorite.   Cole’s Perspective on Riverton Cole finds Riverton both fascinating and unnerving. The town’s mix of ambition, charm, and darkness appeals to his theatrical sensibilities, but its secrets unsettle him. During their live episode at Riverton’s town hall, Cole couldn’t resist needling Lady Lila Black with pointed questions about the town’s leadership. While his humor kept the tone light, his intuition told him there was more to Riverton’s story than met the eye.   Cole has expressed excitement about the possibility of exploring SunnyVale, the ghost town near SteelPort, though he jokingly insists he’ll need a full camera crew and a “backup exorcist” before stepping foot there.   Legacy and Impact Cole St. James has become a vital part of Murder, Mysteries, and Avalon, elevating the podcast from a true crime series to an immersive storytelling experience. His ability to balance humor, drama, and authenticity ensures that even the grimmest tales remain engaging and accessible.   For listeners, Cole is more than just a co-host—he’s a guide through Avalon’s mysteries, offering a theatrical lens through which to view the realm’s darkest corners. And for Jim and Emily, he’s not just a friend but an irreplaceable part of their journey.