“There’s places where the Veil hums like a bad tune—this one sings. Horses died here thinking they were men, and men left with less soul than they came with.”
Description - Exterior
A weather-warped shell of its former glory, the Dexter Park Horse Exchange sits sagging beside rusting rails and weeds that shouldn’t grow in winter. The main auction hall’s roof partially caved in after a storm back in ’47, and what’s left of the redbrick facade is blackened by soot and time. The big iron gates are still chained shut—but never locked.Description - Interior
Inside is worse. The old stalls reek of mold, animal musk, and coppery rot. Rotting tack still hangs on warped posts. The bleachers in the center ring remain mostly intact, though slick with damp. Strange symbols are scratched into the concrete around the auction block. In the sub-basement—sealed for decades—the Crooked Horn now meet under lanterns that never seem to need refueling.History
Built in the 1880s to serve the booming Stockyards, the Horse Exchange was once the largest of its kind in the Midwest. City departments, private buyers, and even traveling circuses came here to trade in flesh and hoof. By the 1930s, the automobile made it obsolete. The building was shuttered officially in 1941—unofficially, it’s never really closed.Owned By
Unofficially claimed by the Crooked Horn, who use it for rituals, initiations, and unlicensed sacrifices.Employees
- None officially—only watchers and wards
- Brenna Knox – site warden and spiritual interpreter for the Horn
- “Tiller” Jack Danvers – groundskeeper in name only, lives in the east stall row
- Roe – mute boy who tends candles and relays messages
- Sister Halfrida – performs the Veil rites tied to the building's original stones
- Unknown entity sometimes referred to as "The Fourth Hoof"
Regulars
- Crooked Horn initiates in training
- Union boys who whisper about hidden tunnels under the floor
- Veil scholars who claim the Exchange is a “binding point”
- One-legged former jockey known as “Saddle Tom” who says he can still hear bidding
- Kids from Canaryville daring each other to step onto the auction block at midnight
- A blind beggar who appears on new moons and vanishes before dawn
Notes
If you hang an iron stirrup from a leather strap and fix it with a brass nail over the arch of Stall Nine, you’ve made the invitation. For three nights straight, whisper through the hollow: “Iron for luck, brass for the door—open the gate, and trade me more.” On the third night, The Trader comes calling. He’s a fey thing in the shape of a small man—skin like furnace coal, eyes like milky glass. Wears a garish old-time suit with too many buttons and a tall, bent top hat that never seems to fall off. He only sticks around for thirty-seven minutes. Long enough to make a deal. Long enough to ruin a life. They say he can grant anything—fame, fortune, love, revenge. But he trades in iron truths and soft regrets, and the price is never what you expect. Some folks claim you can outfox him, walk away with the prize and keep your soul. Course, none of those folks are around to back that up.
Big Louie Manczyk was a horse handler with a busted back and a busted future. He’d been tossed one too many times and couldn’t hold a rake, let alone a saddle. Folks say Louie hung the stirrup and begged The Trader to “walk tall again.”
He got his wish. Next morning, Louie was striding down 47th like he owned the pavement—back straight, boots loud. But then folks started noticing his shadow. It didn’t match him. It lagged, twitched, moved on its own. Sometimes it looked like it was limping behind him, other times it loomed tall and crooked, like it remembered how he used to hurt.
A week later, Louie was gone. Stall Nine was open, but the shadow stayed. To this day, they say when the morning sun hits just right, Louie’s shadow still paces the paddock, dragging an old pain that never let go.
Nadine Portillo ran bets for a bookie out of Pilsen and had a thing for a skittish filly named Sweet Lament. She wasn’t the fastest, wasn’t the strongest—but Nadine swore the horse had a heart nobody else could see. She went to The Trader one wet October night and whispered, “Make her the fastest damn thing in the city.”
And she was. Sweet Lament tore up every track from Stickney to Schiller Park. Couldn’t lose. Problem was, she didn’t stop. First race, she bucked her jockey at the finish and bolted. Second race, she bit through the bit and ran straight into a wall. They tried keeping her in the stables—she kicked through the boards.
Nadine tried to call off the deal, tried burning the stirrup, tried prayer. Last anyone saw of her, she was chasing Sweet Lament down the fog-soaked canal path, both of them screaming like they knew how it would end.
Now folks leave offerings at Stall Nine—not to make a wish, but to undo one.
The Girl in Yellow
There’s a few different stories about where she came from, but the one folks whisper most is this: her name was Lucy Malloy, and she died bad. Someone even dug up an old Tribune clipping—1902, trampled to death at the Exchange. The article’s thin on details, but the neighborhood’s filled in the blanks. They say her father sold her horse, Brownie, without so much as a word. Didn’t just sell him—sold him to a glue man. When Lucy found out, she ran screaming to the paddocks, still in her Sunday yellow dress. The horses spooked—maybe by the storm, maybe by something else—and she got caught in the stampede. Crushed under hooves, broken on her own love. She still shows up now and then, south of the main building where the old corrals once stood. Always in that pale yellow dress, both it and her poor face shattered and torn from her violent end. Mostly she keeps to herself—wanders, watches, weeps. But if someone’s fool enough to bring a horse onto the Exchange grounds? Old timers say don’t try to ride it back out. That’s when she snaps. That’s when the Girl in Yellow remembers what she lost. And she doesn’t let go.Hooks
- Crooked Horn believes this building sits atop a “sympathy fracture” in the Veil—where pain echoes and multiplies
- The horses traded here were often cursed by desperate owners—some say their screams still linger
- Blood poured into the auction ring drains somewhere no one’s mapped—and no one dares follow
- The Exchange’s foundation stones were quarried from a glacial shelf known for pagan rites in Wisconsin
- Certain crooks bring “problem assets” here—those who need to vanish without a trace
- The ghost of a Union Stockyards foreman has been seen walking the perimeter, muttering about missing weight receipts
Comments